{
  "note": "Reconciliation vs chstat.ch 2003 (data-theme 1842, Institute of Federalism / LexFind). ours = concordats with EARLIEST KNOWN EVIDENCE of existence <= 2003 (own enactment date, own version history, or the sibling group's authoritative minimum when the canton's own date is unverified — a concordat is the same act in every member canton), split active / repealed_listed / repealed_by_2003. chstat's table is a 2003 stock snapshot, so acts with a DATED repeal on or before 2003 (repealed_date from LexFind's version_inactive_since) are excluded from the comparison; repeals dated after 2003 or undated stay counted. Authoritative accession dates are kept: a canton that verifiably joined after 2003 is not counted. additional_evidence: memberships proven although the agreement itself is delisted — 'accession' = Beitritt/adhésion instruments in the canton's own collection (agreement not separately published), 'intlex_named' = cantons named in titles of the audited Intlex ≤2003 inventory with neither copy nor accession instrument. unexplained = chstat - explained: concordats delisted from every public trace + accession-vs-decision-date differences (cantons accede at different times; our date is the act's decision date) + undated laws. Audit trail: api/v1/quality/concordat_membership_evidence.json. Improve dates with enrich_dates_lexwork.sh then enrich-dates --siblings.",
  "source_chstat": "https://www.chstat.ch/fr/data-theme/1842/Concordats-par-domaine",
  "chstat_total": 2522,
  "badac_total_memberships": 2564,
  "badac_total_concordats": 733,
  "chstat_vs_badac_unattributed": 42,
  "ours_enacted_until_2003_total": 1934,
  "repealed_by_2003_total": 19,
  "accession_evidence_total": 38,
  "intlex_named_evidence_total": 78,
  "explained_total": 2050,
  "unexplained_total": 472,
  "undated_total": 1,
  "diagnosis_totals": {
    "dating": 12,
    "delisting_or_coverage": 7,
    "reconciled": 4,
    "exceeds_reference": 3
  },
  "year_evidence_le2003": {
    "lexfind_family": 1656,
    "own_enactment": 220,
    "sibling_group": 64,
    "own_versions": 13,
    "undated": 1
  },
  "date_provenance_total": {
    "sibling:GL": 6,
    "sibling:VS": 1,
    "lexfind_family": 1656,
    "sibling:AG": 7,
    "lexwork_api": 33,
    "text": 191,
    "sibling:TG": 1,
    "version_date_only": 54,
    "sibling:BE": 2,
    "sibling:GR": 2
  },
  "cantons": {
    "AG": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 22,
        "sante": 10,
        "educ": 28,
        "infra": 10,
        "eco": 16,
        "fin": 26,
        "total": 112
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 42,
        "repealed_listed": 34,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 76
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 1,
        "intlex_named": 1
      },
      "explained_total": 78,
      "all_time_total": 131,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 34,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 48,
        "text": 13,
        "version_date_only": 1,
        "sibling:BE": 1,
        "lexwork_api": 11,
        "sibling:AG": 2
      }
    },
    "AI": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 15,
        "sante": 6,
        "educ": 20,
        "infra": 5,
        "eco": 8,
        "fin": 12,
        "total": 66
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 33,
        "repealed_listed": 6,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 39
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 2
      },
      "explained_total": 41,
      "all_time_total": 62,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 25,
      "diagnosis": "delisting_or_coverage",
      "date_provenance": {
        "text": 2,
        "lexfind_family": 37
      }
    },
    "AR": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 11,
        "sante": 10,
        "educ": 27,
        "infra": 20,
        "eco": 13,
        "fin": 13,
        "total": 94
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 36,
        "repealed_listed": 12,
        "repealed_by_2003": 1,
        "total": 48
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 6
      },
      "explained_total": 54,
      "all_time_total": 65,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 40,
      "diagnosis": "delisting_or_coverage",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexwork_api": 2,
        "lexfind_family": 44,
        "text": 2,
        "sibling:GL": 1
      }
    },
    "BE": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 33,
        "sante": 14,
        "educ": 43,
        "infra": 5,
        "eco": 16,
        "fin": 29,
        "total": 140
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 33,
        "repealed_listed": 14,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 47
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 1,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 48,
      "all_time_total": 119,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 92,
      "diagnosis": "delisting_or_coverage",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 26,
        "text": 10,
        "lexwork_api": 11
      }
    },
    "BL": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 36,
        "sante": 22,
        "educ": 40,
        "infra": 19,
        "eco": 18,
        "fin": 24,
        "total": 159
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 73,
        "repealed_listed": 56,
        "repealed_by_2003": 3,
        "total": 129
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 1
      },
      "explained_total": 130,
      "all_time_total": 186,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 29,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 116,
        "text": 10,
        "version_date_only": 4,
        "sibling:GL": 1,
        "sibling:BE": 1
      }
    },
    "BS": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 34,
        "sante": 27,
        "educ": 36,
        "infra": 19,
        "eco": 11,
        "fin": 14,
        "total": 141
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 63,
        "repealed_listed": 35,
        "repealed_by_2003": 6,
        "total": 98
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 1,
        "intlex_named": 1
      },
      "explained_total": 100,
      "all_time_total": 141,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 41,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 97,
        "version_date_only": 2,
        "text": 3,
        "lexwork_api": 1,
        "sibling:GL": 1
      }
    },
    "FR": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 17,
        "sante": 10,
        "educ": 29,
        "infra": 6,
        "eco": 14,
        "fin": 16,
        "total": 92
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 41,
        "repealed_listed": 44,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 85
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 85,
      "all_time_total": 126,
      "undated": 1,
      "unexplained": 7,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 71,
        "text": 14
      }
    },
    "GE": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 19,
        "sante": 4,
        "educ": 19,
        "infra": 3,
        "eco": 6,
        "fin": 8,
        "total": 59
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 30,
        "repealed_listed": 22,
        "repealed_by_2003": 1,
        "total": 52
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 52,
      "all_time_total": 75,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 7,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 45,
        "version_date_only": 7,
        "text": 1
      }
    },
    "GL": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 14,
        "sante": 9,
        "educ": 24,
        "infra": 11,
        "eco": 14,
        "fin": 11,
        "total": 83
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 26,
        "repealed_listed": 17,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 43
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 5,
        "intlex_named": 4
      },
      "explained_total": 52,
      "all_time_total": 69,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 31,
      "diagnosis": "delisting_or_coverage",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 39,
        "text": 2,
        "lexwork_api": 1,
        "version_date_only": 1
      }
    },
    "GR": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 14,
        "sante": 7,
        "educ": 23,
        "infra": 3,
        "eco": 7,
        "fin": 13,
        "total": 67
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 22,
        "repealed_listed": 19,
        "repealed_by_2003": 1,
        "total": 41
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 2,
        "intlex_named": 3
      },
      "explained_total": 46,
      "all_time_total": 52,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 21,
      "diagnosis": "delisting_or_coverage",
      "date_provenance": {
        "sibling:GR": 1,
        "lexfind_family": 37,
        "text": 4
      }
    },
    "JU": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 19,
        "sante": 14,
        "educ": 33,
        "infra": 3,
        "eco": 6,
        "fin": 9,
        "total": 84
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 58,
        "repealed_listed": 17,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 75
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 75,
      "all_time_total": 133,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 9,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "text": 33,
        "lexfind_family": 42
      }
    },
    "LU": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 17,
        "sante": 12,
        "educ": 19,
        "infra": 9,
        "eco": 11,
        "fin": 11,
        "total": 79
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 29,
        "repealed_listed": 22,
        "repealed_by_2003": 1,
        "total": 51
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 3
      },
      "explained_total": 54,
      "all_time_total": 81,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 25,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 47,
        "text": 3,
        "sibling:GL": 1,
        "version_date_only": 1
      }
    },
    "NE": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 21,
        "sante": 8,
        "educ": 31,
        "infra": 4,
        "eco": 12,
        "fin": 17,
        "total": 93
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 59,
        "repealed_listed": 21,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 80
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 80,
      "all_time_total": 95,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 13,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "version_date_only": 27,
        "text": 17,
        "lexfind_family": 35,
        "sibling:VS": 1
      }
    },
    "NW": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 20,
        "sante": 14,
        "educ": 26,
        "infra": 11,
        "eco": 13,
        "fin": 2,
        "total": 86
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 39,
        "repealed_listed": 45,
        "repealed_by_2003": 1,
        "total": 84
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 84,
      "all_time_total": 133,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 2,
      "diagnosis": "reconciled",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 80,
        "text": 5
      }
    },
    "OW": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 19,
        "sante": 15,
        "educ": 26,
        "infra": 11,
        "eco": 9,
        "fin": 5,
        "total": 85
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 42,
        "repealed_listed": 41,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 83
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 83,
      "all_time_total": 128,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 2,
      "diagnosis": "reconciled",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 81,
        "text": 2
      }
    },
    "SG": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 22,
        "sante": 23,
        "educ": 50,
        "infra": 49,
        "eco": 45,
        "fin": 29,
        "total": 218
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 123,
        "repealed_listed": 67,
        "repealed_by_2003": 2,
        "total": 190
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 4,
        "intlex_named": 6
      },
      "explained_total": 200,
      "all_time_total": 238,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 18,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 176,
        "text": 6,
        "version_date_only": 10
      }
    },
    "SH": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 14,
        "sante": 9,
        "educ": 21,
        "infra": 6,
        "eco": 8,
        "fin": 11,
        "total": 69
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 30,
        "repealed_listed": 23,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 53
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 10
      },
      "explained_total": 63,
      "all_time_total": 74,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 6,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 51,
        "text": 2
      }
    },
    "SO": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 31,
        "sante": 15,
        "educ": 23,
        "infra": 7,
        "eco": 22,
        "fin": 20,
        "total": 118
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 70,
        "repealed_listed": 32,
        "repealed_by_2003": 1,
        "total": 102
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 6,
        "intlex_named": 2
      },
      "explained_total": 110,
      "all_time_total": 123,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 8,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "text": 11,
        "lexfind_family": 85,
        "sibling:GL": 1,
        "lexwork_api": 6
      }
    },
    "SZ": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 17,
        "sante": 8,
        "educ": 31,
        "infra": 22,
        "eco": 14,
        "fin": 4,
        "total": 96
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 49,
        "repealed_listed": 28,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 77
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 12,
        "intlex_named": 10
      },
      "explained_total": 99,
      "all_time_total": 96,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": -3,
      "diagnosis": "reconciled",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 62,
        "text": 15
      }
    },
    "TG": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 18,
        "sante": 9,
        "educ": 38,
        "infra": 18,
        "eco": 13,
        "fin": 18,
        "total": 114
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 77,
        "repealed_listed": 34,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 111
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 3
      },
      "explained_total": 114,
      "all_time_total": 139,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 0,
      "diagnosis": "reconciled",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 100,
        "text": 8,
        "sibling:GR": 1,
        "lexwork_api": 1,
        "sibling:GL": 1
      }
    },
    "TI": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 13,
        "sante": 3,
        "educ": 18,
        "infra": 2,
        "eco": 6,
        "fin": 2,
        "total": 44
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 20,
        "repealed_listed": 28,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 48
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 4,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 52,
      "all_time_total": 82,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": -8,
      "diagnosis": "exceeds_reference",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 44,
        "text": 4
      }
    },
    "UR": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 17,
        "sante": 7,
        "educ": 15,
        "infra": 9,
        "eco": 9,
        "fin": 10,
        "total": 67
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 25,
        "repealed_listed": 19,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 44
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 1
      },
      "explained_total": 45,
      "all_time_total": 57,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 22,
      "diagnosis": "delisting_or_coverage",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 40,
        "version_date_only": 1,
        "sibling:AG": 1,
        "text": 2
      }
    },
    "VD": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 20,
        "sante": 7,
        "educ": 26,
        "infra": 10,
        "eco": 12,
        "fin": 23,
        "total": 98
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 43,
        "repealed_listed": 16,
        "repealed_by_2003": 1,
        "total": 59
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 0
      },
      "explained_total": 59,
      "all_time_total": 100,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 39,
      "diagnosis": "dating",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 60
      }
    },
    "VS": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 14,
        "sante": 4,
        "educ": 19,
        "infra": 4,
        "eco": 7,
        "fin": 15,
        "total": 63
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 16,
        "repealed_listed": 13,
        "repealed_by_2003": 1,
        "total": 29
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 1
      },
      "explained_total": 30,
      "all_time_total": 62,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": 33,
      "diagnosis": "delisting_or_coverage",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 28,
        "text": 1,
        "sibling:TG": 1
      }
    },
    "ZG": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 15,
        "sante": 5,
        "educ": 19,
        "infra": 4,
        "eco": 10,
        "fin": 15,
        "total": 68
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 42,
        "repealed_listed": 29,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 71
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 2,
        "intlex_named": 3
      },
      "explained_total": 76,
      "all_time_total": 122,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": -8,
      "diagnosis": "exceeds_reference",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 69,
        "text": 2
      }
    },
    "ZH": {
      "chstat_2003": {
        "etat": 21,
        "sante": 8,
        "educ": 28,
        "infra": 27,
        "eco": 13,
        "fin": 30,
        "total": 127
      },
      "ours_enacted_until_2003": {
        "active": 94,
        "repealed_listed": 25,
        "repealed_by_2003": 0,
        "total": 119
      },
      "additional_evidence": {
        "accession": 0,
        "intlex_named": 21
      },
      "explained_total": 140,
      "all_time_total": 151,
      "undated": 0,
      "unexplained": -13,
      "diagnosis": "exceeds_reference",
      "date_provenance": {
        "lexfind_family": 96,
        "sibling:AG": 4,
        "text": 19
      }
    }
  }
}